After a long hiatus due to busy schedules and severe lack of sleep, some of which I attribute to the dog-coyote hybrids that our next door neighbors apparently own, it's time for an update on my silverware situation.
Congratulations. The majority of you (57%) picked Drawer #3. Here is a view of that drawer from a slightly different perspective:
Thanks to everyone who put in their vote for me to keep my silverware in the bathroom. Apparently the distance from the kitchen and the reduced sanitation levels do not faze you.
Some of the other suggestions I received were a magnetic knife strip (not sure how silverware is supposed to stick to that), a caddy, and to do away with silverware entirely (thanks Greg - you can come make our peanut butter sandwiches). No one voted for drawers 1 or 2, which are the only drawers that are actually in the kitchen.
I guess it's back to square one. I like this square and I'm thinking of getting it: Shesham Flatware Caddy from Crate & Barrel. Although it is a bit pricey for a silverware caddy, it does have space for all my salad forks and spoons whose names I haven't yet figured out. Let me know what you think in the comments - should I go with this, or keep trying?